Teams By Year In Supporters' Shield Standings
(The Supporters' Shield was not awarded until 1999)
1996
- Tampa Bay Mutiny
- Los Angeles Galaxy
- D.C. United
- Dallas Burn
- Kansas City Wiz
- San Jose Clash
- New York/New Jersey MetroStars
- Columbus Crew
- New England Revolution
- Colorado Rapids
1997
- D.C. United
- Kansas City Wizards
- Tampa Bay Mutiny
- Los Angeles Galaxy
- Dallas Burn
- Columbus Crew
- Colorado Rapids
- New England Revolution
- New York/New Jersey MetroStars
- San Jose Clash
1998
- Los Angeles Galaxy
- D.C. United
- Chicago Fire
- Columbus Crew
- Colorado Rapids
- MetroStars
- Dallas Burn
- Miami Fusion
- Tampa Bay Mutiny
- San Jose Clash
- Kansas City Wizards
- New England Revolution
1999
- D.C. United
- Los Angeles Galaxy
- Dallas Burn
- Chicago Fire
- Colorado Rapids
- Columbus Crew
- San Jose Clash
- Tampa Bay Mutiny
- Miami Fusion
- New England Revolution
- Kansas City Wizards
- MetroStars
2000
- Kansas City Wizards
- Chicago Fire
- MetroStars
- Tampa Bay Mutiny
- Los Angeles Galaxy
- Dallas Burn
- New England Revolution
- Colorado Rapids
- Miami Fusion
- Columbus Crew
- D.C. United
- San Jose Earthquakes
2001
- Miami Fusion F.C.
- Chicago Fire
- Los Angeles Galaxy
- San Jose Earthquakes
- Columbus Crew
- MetroStars
- Kansas City Wizards
- Dallas Burn
- New England Revolution
- D.C. United
- Colorado Rapids
- Tampa Bay Mutiny
2002
- Los Angeles Galaxy
- San Jose Earthquakes
- Dallas Burn
- Colorado Rapids
- New England Revolution
- Columbus Crew
- Chicago Fire
- Kansas City Wizards
- MetroStars
- D.C. United
2003
- Chicago Fire
- San Jose Earthquakes
- New England Revolution
- Kansas City Wizards
- MetroStars
- Colorado Rapids
- D.C. United
- Columbus Crew
- Los Angeles Galaxy
- Dallas Burn
2004
- Columbus Crew
- Kansas City Wizards
- Los Angeles Galaxy
- D.C. United
- Colorado Rapids
- MetroStars
- San Jose Earthquakes
- Dallas Burn
- New England Revolution
- Chicago Fire
2005
- San Jose Earthquakes
- New England Revolution
- D.C. United
- Chicago Fire
- FC Dallas
- MetroStars
- Colorado Rapids
- Los Angeles Galaxy
- Kansas City Wizards
- Columbus Crew
- Real Salt Lake
- Chivas USA
2006
- D.C. United
- FC Dallas
- New England Revolution
- Chicago Fire
- Houston Dynamo
- Chivas USA
- Colorado Rapids
- New York Red Bulls
- Los Angeles Galaxy
- Real Salt Lake
- Kansas City Wizards
- Columbus Crew
2007
- D.C. United
- Chivas USA
- Houston Dynamo
- New England Revolution
- FC Dallas
- New York Red Bulls
- Chicago Fire
- Kansas City Wizards
- Columbus Crew
- Colorado Rapids
- LA Galaxy
- Real Salt Lake
- Toronto FC
2008
- Columbus Crew
- Houston Dynamo
- Chicago Fire
- New England Revolution
- Chivas USA
- Kansas City Wizards
- Real Salt Lake
- New York Red Bulls
- Colorado Rapids
- D.C. United
- FC Dallas
- Toronto FC
- LA Galaxy
- San Jose Earthquakes
2009
- Columbus Crew
- Los Angeles Galaxy
- Houston Dynamo
- Seattle Sounders FC
- Chicago Fire
- Chivas USA
- New England Revolution
- Real Salt Lake
- Colorado Rapids
- D.C. United
- FC Dallas
- Toronto FC
- Kansas City Wizards
- San Jose Earthquakes
- New York Red Bulls
2010
- Los Angeles Galaxy
- Real Salt Lake
- New York Red Bulls
- FC Dallas
- Columbus Crew
- Seattle Sounders FC
- Colorado Rapids
- San Jose Earthquakes
- Kansas City Wizards
- Chicago Fire
- Toronto FC
- Houston Dynamo
- New England Revolution
- Philadelphia Union
- Chivas USA
- D.C. United
2011
- LA Galaxy
- Seattle Sounders FC
- Real Salt Lake
- FC Dallas
- Sporting Kansas City
- Houston Dynamo
- Colorado Rapids
- Philadelphia Union
- Columbus Crew
- New York Red Bulls
- Chicago Fire
- Portland Timbers
- D.C. United
- San Jose Earthquakes
- Chivas USA
- Toronto FC
- New England Revolution
- Vancouver Whitecaps FC
2012
- San Jose Earthquakes
- Sporting Kansas City
- D.C. United
- New York Red Bulls
- Real Salt Lake
- Chicago Fire
- Seattle Sounders FC
- LA Galaxy
- Houston Dynamo
- Columbus Crew
- Vancouver Whitecaps FC
- Montréal Impact
- FC Dallas
- Colorado Rapids
- Philadelphia Union
- New England Revolution
- Portland Timbers
- Chivas USA
- Toronto FC
2013
- New York Red Bulls
- Sporting Kansas City
- Portland Timbers
- Real Salt Lake
- LA Galaxy
- Seattle Sounders FC
- New England Revolution
- Colorado Rapids
- Houston Dynamo
- San Jose Earthquakes
- Montréal Impact
- Chicago Fire
- Vancouver Whitecaps FC
- Philadelphia Union
- FC Dallas
- Columbus Crew
- Toronto FC
- Chivas USA
- D.C. United
2014 (July 31 Standings)
- Seattle Sounders FC
- Sporting Kansas City
- D.C. United
- Real Salt Lake
- LA Galaxy
- Colorado Rapids
- FC Dallas
- Vancouver Whitecaps
- Portland Timbers
- New England Revolution
- Toronto FC
- Columbus Crew
- New York Red Bulls
- Chivas USA
- Philadelphia Union
- Chicago Fire
- San Jose Earthquakes
- Houston Dynamo
- Montréal Impact
2015 (In Alphabetical Order)
- Chicago Fire
- Chivas USA (To Be Sold and Rebranded)
- Colorado Rapids
- Columbus Crew
- D.C. United
- FC Dallas
- Houston Dynamo
- LA Galaxy
- Montréal Impact
- New England Revolution
- New York City FC
- New York Red Bulls
- Orlando City SC
- Philadelphia Union
- Portland Timbers
- Real Salt Lake
- San Jose Earthquakes
- Seattle Sounders FC
- Sporting Kansas City
- Toronto FC
- Vancouver Whitecaps FC